Skip to content
sellNotable cluster of 7

Cary D McMillan sold $163k of AEO

director at AMERICAN EAGLE OUTFITTERS INC. 9,002 shares at an average of $18.12, traded Sep 8, 2025, filed Sep 10, 2025.

Warning score
61
Value
$163k
9,002 shares
Holdings after
0
-100% from before
From 52-week low
+99%
low $8.89, close $17.71
From 52-week high
-15%
high $20.83, as of Sep 8, 2025

Score components

  • Role
    Director
    +15
  • Trade size
    $163k at market
    +11
  • Share of holdings sold
    Sold 100% of holdings
    +20
  • Cluster
    7 insiders selling within 14 days
    +15

What happened after comparable sells

Same side and tier, against the S&P 500, at 1, 3 and 6 months. Shown to Pro users; the whole table is on the backtest page.

Price around the trade, and since

From a quarter before the trade to today. The arrow is the trade, the circle the day the filing reached EDGAR, which is the first day anyone outside could act; the dotted line is the S&P 500 rebased to that day's close.

AEOOct 9, 2026 · close 18.17
Since filing Sep 10, 2025: -2.3%SPY +21.0% · excess -23.3%

Daily candles, adjusted for splits and dividends. Green arrows are insider buys, red are sells, sized by value; the dashed line is the close on the filing day, the dotted line SPY rebased to it.Charts by TradingView Lightweight Charts™

Rows in this filing

Every transaction in Form 4 0001225208-25-007858, as filed. Open on EDGAR

DateTransactionSharesPriceValueHoldings afterFiled
Sep 8, 2025SOpen-market sale
Common Stock, without par value
-9,002$18.12$163k0Sep 10, 2025

Related signals

Other insiders at AMERICAN EAGLE OUTFITTERS INC and this insider’s other filings.

ScoreCompanyInsiderValueHoldingsFiled
51Moderate
AEOsell 2
AMERICAN EAGLE OUTFITTERS INC
Cary D McMillan
director
$66k
3,617 shares
-100%
51Moderate
AEOsell 2
AMERICAN EAGLE OUTFITTERS INC
Noel Joseph Spiegel
director
$64k
3,617 shares
-100%
50Moderate
AEOsell 2
AMERICAN EAGLE OUTFITTERS INC
Noel Joseph Spiegel
director
$50k
2,887 shares
-100%
50Moderate
AEOsell 2
AMERICAN EAGLE OUTFITTERS INC
Cary D McMillan
director
$50k
2,887 shares
-100%
57Moderate
AEOsell 3
AMERICAN EAGLE OUTFITTERS INC
Noel Joseph Spiegel
director
$49k
1,896 shares
-100%
70Notable
AEOsell 3
AMERICAN EAGLE OUTFITTERS INC
Jay L Schottenstein
Exec Chairman & CEO
$27M
1,048,579 shares
-14%
57Moderate
AEOsell 3
AMERICAN EAGLE OUTFITTERS INC
Cary D McMillan
director
$50k
1,896 shares
-100%
51Moderate
AEOsell 4
AMERICAN EAGLE OUTFITTERS INC
James H Keefer JR
SVP, Controller & CAO
$135k
5,742 shares
-34%
60Notable
AEOsell 4
AMERICAN EAGLE OUTFITTERS INC
Marisa Baldwin
EVP - CHRO
$1.4M
61,319 shares
-72%
65Notable
AEOsell 4
AMERICAN EAGLE OUTFITTERS INC
Jennifer M. Foyle
Global Brand President-aerie
$5.9M
243,047 shares
-56%

Not investment advice. Scores and forward returns are decision support built from public SEC filings and past prices; they describe what happened after comparable filings, not what will happen after this one. Do your own research and size your risk.

Cary D McMillan sold $163k of AEO | InsiderTell