Skip to content
buyModerate cluster of 5

Thomas A McCarthy bought $194k of SIGI

director at SELECTIVE INSURANCE GROUP INC. 2,500 shares at an average of $77.42, traded Jul 28, 2025, filed Jul 29, 2025.

Conviction score
59
Value
$194k
2,500 shares
Holdings after
18,746
+15% from before
From 52-week low
+5%
low $73.16, close $76.51
From 52-week high
-22%
high $98.70, as of Jul 28, 2025

Score components

  • Role
    Director
    +15
  • Trade size
    $194k at market
    +12
  • Relative to holdings
    Holdings up 15%
    +3
  • Price context
    5% above the 52-week low; 22% below the 52-week high
    +14
  • Cluster
    5 insiders buying within 14 days
    +15
  • Repeat buying
    First buy in 90 days
    0
  • Track record
    Too few past buys to judge (0 with prices)
    0

What happened after comparable buys

Same side and tier, against the S&P 500, at 1, 3 and 6 months. Shown to Pro users; the whole table is on the backtest page.

Price around the trade, and since

From a quarter before the trade to today. The arrow is the trade, the circle the day the filing reached EDGAR, which is the first day anyone outside could act; the dotted line is the S&P 500 rebased to that day's close.

SIGIOct 9, 2026 · close 84.22
Since filing Jul 29, 2025: +6.6%SPY +24.2% · excess -17.7%

Daily candles, adjusted for splits and dividends. Green arrows are insider buys, red are sells, sized by value; the dashed line is the close on the filing day, the dotted line SPY rebased to it.Charts by TradingView Lightweight Charts™

Rows in this filing

Every transaction in Form 4 0001225208-25-006833, as filed. Open on EDGAR

DateTransactionSharesPriceValueHoldings afterFiled
Jul 28, 2025POpen-market purchase
Common Stockindirect: By Trust
+2,500$77.42$194k18,746Jul 29, 2025

Related signals

Other insiders at SELECTIVE INSURANCE GROUP INC and this insider’s other filings.

ScoreCompanyInsiderValueHoldingsFiled
25Weak
SIGIsell
SELECTIVE INSURANCE GROUP INC
Anthony D. Harnett
SVP, Chief Accounting Officer
$93k
1,064 shares
-7%
25Weak
SIGIbuy
SELECTIVE INSURANCE GROUP INC
Lisa R Bacus
director
$51k
600 shares
+10%
24Weak
SIGIsell
SELECTIVE INSURANCE GROUP INC
Anthony D. Harnett
SVP, Chief Accounting Officer
$81k
955 shares
-6%
51Moderate
SIGIbuy
SELECTIVE INSURANCE GROUP INC
Patrick Sean Brennan
EVP, Chief Financial Officer
$206k
2,700 shares
+18%
57Moderate
SIGIbuy 5
SELECTIVE INSURANCE GROUP INC
Robert Kelly Doherty
director
$116k
1,500 shares
+6%
67Notable
SIGIbuy 5
SELECTIVE INSURANCE GROUP INC
John J. Marchioni
President and CEO
$249k
3,200 shares
+2%
58Moderate
SIGIbuy 5
SELECTIVE INSURANCE GROUP INC
Terrence W Cavanaugh
director
$151k
2,000 shares
+9%
57Moderate
SIGIbuy 5
SELECTIVE INSURANCE GROUP INC
Joseph Eppers
EVP, Chief Investment Officer
$108k
1,402 shares
+13%
25Weak
SIGIsell
SELECTIVE INSURANCE GROUP INC
Anthony D. Harnett
SVP, Chief Accounting Officer
$118k
1,352 shares
-8%
49Moderate
SIGIbuy 2
SELECTIVE INSURANCE GROUP INC
Patrick Sean Brennan
EVP, Chief Financial Officer
$249k
3,000 shares
+25%

Not investment advice. Scores and forward returns are decision support built from public SEC filings and past prices; they describe what happened after comparable filings, not what will happen after this one. Do your own research and size your risk.

Thomas A McCarthy bought $194k of SIGI | InsiderTell